|
Author
|
Topic: Should the US had dropped the atomic bomb?
|
-gbotto600-
Addicted Member
Member # 155
Rate Member
|
posted
i think: YESa invasion of Japan would have killed many more Japanese and Americans. the Japanese had thousands of sucidie subs and boats waiting for the US invasion fleet. the Russians would have also invaded and we would probaly have had a Berlin like suitation in Japan with the Russian's holding thier terroirty and NATO holding theirs. i think also by dropping it, we also stopped any further atomic attacks by showing the world how terrible it was as a weapon, i guess it kind of scared any other nation from using it interesting fact: the plan for the invasion of Japan had the 3rd Marine division landing first, this unit had only 5 days of orders because the commanders expected it to be totally destoryed after 5 days... discuss it!  [ July 08, 2001: Message edited by: -gbotto600- ]
-------------------- Decima MAS \ When ancient Rome was near defeat, the invincible Tenth Legion was raised: they beat the barbarians on the battlefield and Rome gained peace with honour again. When the traitor, on September the eighth, left the fatherland in infamy, the Tenth Flotilla was raised from the sea and it brought weapons at the cry for honour!
Oh our Tenth Flotilla, you that mocked England, you victorious on Alexandria, Malta, Souda and Gibraltar, you already victorious upon the sea, now even on the dry land you will win!
To you Italian ships, stolen from us not in battle but by treason, and to you, our prisoners and dead brothers, we swear: we swear that we'll came back, let this be God's and the Flag's will. We swear that we'll fight until we obtain an honourable peace!
Posts: 7713 (0.83 per day) | From: NJ | Registered: May 2001 (9291 days)
| IP: Logged |
|
|
-Soul Blade-
Unregistered
|
posted
I think that the whole war should not have happened in the first place, but in the context of the war, i'd say Yes, the bomb should have been dropped. Otherwise there would have been many more deaths of Japanese and Americans, as gb said.
IP: Logged |
|
|
|
|
Ifyourwondering
Member
Member # 4
Rate Member
|
posted
to be honest i dont really care. u war geeks are really gettin on my tits
-------------------- ALL THE LADS WANNA BE ME, ALL THE BIRDS WANNA SHAG ME!

GOD GAVE ME A SOUL, IN YOUR ROCK N ROLL, BABE!
Posts: 2154 (0.23 per day) | From: Lancashire, England | Registered: May 2001 (9291 days)
| IP: Logged |
|
|
-Soul Blade-
Unregistered
|
posted
What!? You're calling me a war geek!?!? I am totally against war, man, so just don't say stuff like that until you're 100% sure you're right.
IP: Logged |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Ifyourwondering
Member
Member # 4
Rate Member
|
posted
listen guys. its really sad talking about war all the fuckin time. do u guys play football? do u ever go out? do u not get sick of talkin about that fuckin war. and your fuckin sigs have all these fuckin stupid sayings on as if your a fuckin Japanese Ninja - u sound less convincing than master splinter off turtles. who cares abou the fuckin WAFFENN SS or woteva, fucking hell.
-------------------- ALL THE LADS WANNA BE ME, ALL THE BIRDS WANNA SHAG ME!

GOD GAVE ME A SOUL, IN YOUR ROCK N ROLL, BABE!
Posts: 2154 (0.23 per day) | From: Lancashire, England | Registered: May 2001 (9291 days)
| IP: Logged |
|
|
pdykstra600
Senior Member
Member # 7
Rate Member
|
posted
i say YES to the dropping of the bomb. Ending the war quickly saved many Allied POW's lives. Japan wanted to cover up Unit 731 so they would have killed all the allied POWs had the war not ended quickly.
Posts: 4159 (0.44 per day) | From: new jersey | Registered: May 2001 (9291 days)
| IP: Logged |
|
|
Ifyourwondering
Member
Member # 4
Rate Member
|
posted
yeah but its still a boring subject
-------------------- ALL THE LADS WANNA BE ME, ALL THE BIRDS WANNA SHAG ME!

GOD GAVE ME A SOUL, IN YOUR ROCK N ROLL, BABE!
Posts: 2154 (0.23 per day) | From: Lancashire, England | Registered: May 2001 (9291 days)
| IP: Logged |
|
|
|
|
Ifyourwondering
Member
Member # 4
Rate Member
|
posted
its fcking boring tho. gods sake. who wants to talk about war? i wouldnt wanna go to one of your party's it'd be a proper yawn fest. with geeks playing warhammer
-------------------- ALL THE LADS WANNA BE ME, ALL THE BIRDS WANNA SHAG ME!

GOD GAVE ME A SOUL, IN YOUR ROCK N ROLL, BABE!
Posts: 2154 (0.23 per day) | From: Lancashire, England | Registered: May 2001 (9291 days)
| IP: Logged |
|
|
|
|
pdykstra600
Senior Member
Member # 7
Rate Member
|
posted
no, Japan would not surrendor, they would suicide bomb the americans before they surrendered. Japan didnt even surrendor after the first bomb was dropped, thats why they dropped the second one.
Posts: 4159 (0.44 per day) | From: new jersey | Registered: May 2001 (9291 days)
| IP: Logged |
|
|
SweepZ
Member
Member # 149
Member Rated:
|
posted
and your sig about wanting birds to gang rape you is cool? wow i wish i was british
-------------------- Laziness is a prize not a fault U told me not to daydream...well dont be so boring Nothing gold can stay Sick and tired of all this christmas cheer.
Posts: 692 (0.07 per day) | From: MICHIGAN | Registered: Jun 2001 (9249 days)
| IP: Logged |
|
|
uknemesis
Member
Member # 3
Member Rated:
|
posted
Europia, I had to do an in-depth essay on this subject a while ago. Facts are:Japan was training civilians to either suicidally attack the US when they landed, or to stay behind enemy lines and hamper their efforts by sabotage, etc. Japan was willing to fight to the last man, only a weapon which could kill them without them fighting back scared them enough to surrender. And PD's right, the first caused some outrage, but with a few people saying that it must be the only one America had, and the Japs thinking it may be a bombardment before an invasion, they continued to fight. The second bomb shocked the Japanese into surrender, and the people saying America only had one bomb were silenced. Bushido called for a fight to the end, but they were being killed without fighting anything, so they surrendered. Nemesis
--------------------  President Nemesis of the People's Republic of China
With the might of Xin Sheng, China will rise once more!
Posts: 1580 (0.17 per day) | Registered: May 2001 (9291 days)
| IP: Logged |
|
|
|
|
SweepZ
Member
Member # 149
Member Rated:
|
posted
take a quick glance at your sig and you'll see i was elaborating....
-------------------- Laziness is a prize not a fault U told me not to daydream...well dont be so boring Nothing gold can stay Sick and tired of all this christmas cheer.
Posts: 692 (0.07 per day) | From: MICHIGAN | Registered: Jun 2001 (9249 days)
| IP: Logged |
|
|
Ifyourwondering
Member
Member # 4
Rate Member
|
posted
eleaborate all u want, i dont have a fetish with poultry or the like, unlike redeemer....
-------------------- ALL THE LADS WANNA BE ME, ALL THE BIRDS WANNA SHAG ME!

GOD GAVE ME A SOUL, IN YOUR ROCK N ROLL, BABE!
Posts: 2154 (0.23 per day) | From: Lancashire, England | Registered: May 2001 (9291 days)
| IP: Logged |
|
|
-ReDeeMeR
Administrator
Member # 5
Member Rated:
|
posted
another flame, thats it i am going to ban him myself
-------------------- 
Posts: 5617 (0.6 per day) | From: Anytown | Registered: May 2001 (9304 days)
| IP: Logged |
|
|
|
|
|
|
-ReDeeMeR
Administrator
Member # 5
Member Rated:
|
posted
i blame arkan, last time i complained about uffy flaming in the general forum, arkan said "i'll threaten the living shit out of him.", but in actual fact he said nothing
-------------------- 
Posts: 5617 (0.6 per day) | From: Anytown | Registered: May 2001 (9304 days)
| IP: Logged |
|
|
-ReDeeMeR
Administrator
Member # 5
Member Rated:
|
posted
quote: Originally posted by uknemesis: For fuck's sake, can't the flaming law be loosened up a bit? When you post in the general you've got to watch everything you say incase "nagging old woman" Redeemer takes it the wrong way! Redeemer, loosen the apron strings a bit, eh? You sound like a bitter old hag! And yes, that was a flame, and I don't give a fuck.But seriously, the laws need to be relaxed, I know that until I became the mod there and then had to post there, I wouldn't go near the general cause it's so strict in comparison to the flamers. Nemesis
"and I don't give a fuck.", well i do, let me remind you that iffy repeatedly and deliberately broke the rules and action had to be taken
-------------------- 
Posts: 5617 (0.6 per day) | From: Anytown | Registered: May 2001 (9304 days)
| IP: Logged |
|
|
|
|
|
|
pdykstra600
Senior Member
Member # 7
Rate Member
|
posted
lol  How long is this ban of iffy's gonna be?
Posts: 4159 (0.44 per day) | From: new jersey | Registered: May 2001 (9291 days)
| IP: Logged |
|
|
uknemesis
Member
Member # 3
Member Rated:
|
posted
Arkan, this was a General Forum topic, only moved cause Redeemer hates iffy so much, so light flames should be allowed just as they should be in the general. And somehow I don't think the punishment would be to send me to Texas, you're not that evil, are you?!  As for iffy getting a ban, that would be suicide, he's a regular poster, and this board needs everyone of those it can get... Even Redeemer, unfortunately...Nemesis
--------------------  President Nemesis of the People's Republic of China
With the might of Xin Sheng, China will rise once more!
Posts: 1580 (0.17 per day) | Registered: May 2001 (9291 days)
| IP: Logged |
|
|
KONAN
Member
Member # 75
Member Rated:
|
posted
Will this thread get moved to one of the war forums where it belongs? I will leave it to you guys.
-------------------- Ravaged by a Savage - Konan 2001  Beauty/strength/power/the ability to lead others, etc are all a thing of spirit that comes from within and has little or nothing to do with what region you reside/the amount of pigment in one’s skin/genetics/upbringing/etc.–Konan 2001
Posts: 2409 (0.25 per day) | From: Frozen Wasteland called Canada | Registered: May 2001 (9281 days)
| IP: Logged |
|
|
Arkan
| | UßerAdmin  | |
Member # 1
Rate Member
|
posted
Nemesis, no, the punishment is death as they have the death penalty in texas, duhhhh. Oh, and yeah, please move it to the cobwebby war-forum but someone please remove the posts of the warring moderators/admins above, it'd hurt the community for them to hear it.
-------------------- "All This fucking self knowledge, where the fuck has it got me?" - Tony Soprano

If you have a problem or need any help or advice in regards to the forum, email me at ultravision23@hotmail.com. If you want the speediest resolution of your problem, try to be descriptive about the problem as possible and give me your username. I know this is rather cliched but from experience trust me it helps, thank you.
for all other enquiries, visit my Arkans Fan Center
Posts: 10646 (1.14 per day) | From: London Calling | Registered: May 2001 (9291 days)
| IP: Logged |
|
|
-ReDeeMeR
Administrator
Member # 5
Member Rated:
|
posted
quote: Originally posted by uknemesis: Arkan, this was a General Forum topic, only moved cause Redeemer hates iffy so much, so light flames should be allowed just as they should be in the general. And somehow I don't think the punishment would be to send me to Texas, you're not that evil, are you?!  As for iffy getting a ban, that would be suicide, he's a regular poster, and this board needs everyone of those it can get... Even Redeemer, unfortunately...Nemesis
nemesis "i dont have a fetish with poultry or the like, unlike redeemer...." is not a light flame, so even with your 'rule-making' action would be taken
-------------------- 
Posts: 5617 (0.6 per day) | From: Anytown | Registered: May 2001 (9304 days)
| IP: Logged |
|
|
-ReDeeMeR
Administrator
Member # 5
Member Rated:
|
posted
i wonder why nemesis was not complaining this much when SB was banned?
-------------------- 
Posts: 5617 (0.6 per day) | From: Anytown | Registered: May 2001 (9304 days)
| IP: Logged |
|
|
catpatter
Regular
Member # 47
Member Rated:
|
posted
god i cant believe how such a good topic was ruined by childish flaming!, i however will try to get it back on track with an opinion of my own.first of all i believe the bomb should of been dropped, but i also believe all the people who agree with me, agree with me for the wrong reasons. alrighty....lets get this out of the way first. europia was completely right. there was meetings between the governemnts of japan and the ussr to broker a piece deal, pdykstra, im sorry but ur reply to europia was incorrect, (im not going to quote it, takes to fucking long.) but all this crazy talk of suicide bombing is crazy , for the following reasons. 1. there industry had grinded to a halt from the large scale bombing done by the americans, they simply did not have the planes. 2. no fuel,american sumbarines had cut off japanese supplies almost completely, so even if they had the planes, they could not fly them. 3. and simply they had no trained pilots left, and you cant fly a plane without a pilot, simple as that. so that argumernt is completely ludicrous. next thing...., nemisis, you say they were bieng trained for suicide attacks?? come on, they are called suicide attacks for a reason BECUASE THEY DIE WITHOUT ACHIEVING THERE OBJECTIVES. these suicide attackes, were done simply for the sake of saving honour, and had minimal success in battle. anyway, i believe all arguments for "no" are void becuase we simply cannot speculate on what would of happened if the bombs were not dropped, the political, military, and econmic dimensions are far to complex for that.
the bomb should of been dropped , in my books, simply becuase it led ( eventually ) to the winning of the cold war.( by the good guys of caorse )( sorry europia ) -anyway, theres is much more to talk about this, so keep those posts comming boys
-------------------- who needs power when you have people to suck up to u!
Posts: 177 (0.01 per day) | From: earth | Registered: May 2001 (9290 days)
| IP: Logged |
|
|
The Dude
Member
Member # 52
|
posted
quote: Originally posted by catpatter:
next thing...., nemisis, you say they were bieng trained for suicide attacks?? come on, they are called suicide attacks for a reason BECUASE THEY DIE WITHOUT ACHIEVING THERE OBJECTIVES. these suicide attackes, were done simply for the sake of saving honour, and had minimal success in battle. anyway, i believe all arguments for "no" are void becuase we simply cannot speculate on what would of happened if the bombs were not dropped, the political, military, and econmic dimensions are far to complex for that.
the bomb should of been dropped , in my books, simply becuase it led ( eventually ) to the winning of the cold war.( by the good guys of caorse )( sorry europia ) -anyway, theres is much more to talk about this, so keep those posts comming boys
yeah i completely agree with you! If the bomb wouldnt have been dropped in WWII, then nuking would have started in the cold war, which could have lead to a nuclear war. Also i agree with the suicide attacks part. These attacks cant guarantee victory, meaning the japanese army would have got the same results without the things (not for a particular attack, but in general)
Posts: 2335 (0.25 per day) | Registered: May 2001 (9289 days)
| IP: Logged |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
catpatter
Regular
Member # 47
Member Rated:
|
posted
i like the national missile defence idea, anything that shoots down nukes are fine by me
-------------------- who needs power when you have people to suck up to u!
Posts: 177 (0.01 per day) | From: earth | Registered: May 2001 (9290 days)
| IP: Logged |
|
|
|
|
catpatter
Regular
Member # 47
Member Rated:
|
posted
god dont get me started on cloning, that is wrong wrong wrong, listen eurpoia i dont care what ur ideoligy is, we must all agree that cloning is wrong, it is morally wrong, and just plain freaky., they shouldnt even be aloud to clone sheep
-------------------- who needs power when you have people to suck up to u!
Posts: 177 (0.01 per day) | From: earth | Registered: May 2001 (9290 days)
| IP: Logged |
|
|
|
|
|
|
2-D..
Does this rag smell like chloroform to you?
Member # 112
Member Rated:
|
posted
why didnt they then? 
-------------------- *Coming soon: Something so awesome to look at it will make your eyeballs explode*
Posts: 6460 (0.69 per day) | From: Hadleys Hope | Registered: Jun 2001 (9267 days)
| IP: Logged |
|
|
catpatter
Regular
Member # 47
Member Rated:
|
posted
indecision. just how your country dosnt share a common ideology niether did theres, there were peace and war factions in the government at the time, and no descision could be reached for pease in the 2-1 days between the 2nd and 1st nukes. i can see how some people think that the 2nd was used for questionable reasons, but i do believe it should have been dropped.
-------------------- who needs power when you have people to suck up to u!
Posts: 177 (0.01 per day) | From: earth | Registered: May 2001 (9290 days)
| IP: Logged |
|
|
-gbotto600-
Addicted Member
Member # 155
Rate Member
|
posted
I can't beleive 'catpatter' denied the Japanese had sucide special attack squads, what an idiot;
Now lets get this topic going again, i still stick by my thoughts on this, now come on folks, DISCUSS!
Posts: 7713 (0.83 per day) | From: NJ | Registered: May 2001 (9291 days)
| IP: Logged |
|
|
Shagi_Fighter
Monkey See Monkey Do
Member # 443
Rate Member
|
posted
HELLO HELLO
I agree with the very first post. Bombs stopped the war. If the bombs were not dropped the war would have kept going and more Americans and Japenese would have died. Well more would have died if the war had kept going than if the bombs were dropped.
One thing is for sure. I wouldn't have wanted to be the President who ordered those things to be dropped.
-------------------- 
Posts: 5935 (0.66 per day) | From: USA | Registered: Mar 2002 (8984 days)
| IP: Logged |
|
|
-gbotto600-
Addicted Member
Member # 155
Rate Member
|
posted
Ok i moved this topic to the General Forum...
DISCUSS!
Posts: 7713 (0.83 per day) | From: NJ | Registered: May 2001 (9291 days)
| IP: Logged |
|
|
-ReDeeMeR
Administrator
Member # 5
Member Rated:
|
posted
quote: Originally posted by -gbotto600-: I can't beleive 'catpatter' denied the Japanese had sucide special attack squads, what an idiot;
Now lets get this topic going again, i still stick by my thoughts on this, now come on folks, DISCUSS!
ah not another old topic
-------------------- 
Posts: 5617 (0.6 per day) | From: Anytown | Registered: May 2001 (9304 days)
| IP: Logged |
|
|
-gbotto600-
Addicted Member
Member # 155
Rate Member
|
posted
just talk about it amjel
Posts: 7713 (0.83 per day) | From: NJ | Registered: May 2001 (9291 days)
| IP: Logged |
|
|
-ReDeeMeR
Administrator
Member # 5
Member Rated:
|
posted
in future if you are going to refer to me by name, please make sure you get it right
-------------------- 
Posts: 5617 (0.6 per day) | From: Anytown | Registered: May 2001 (9304 days)
| IP: Logged |
|
|
-gbotto600-
Addicted Member
Member # 155
Rate Member
|
posted
A???l
Posts: 7713 (0.83 per day) | From: NJ | Registered: May 2001 (9291 days)
| IP: Logged |
|
|
|